Post 23: Talking History: Italian Unification Podcast

The brothers Ashwell, Benjamin and Adam, are a pair of theoretical chemistry PhD students with a passion for history. Inspired by other history podcasts (most notably Mike Duncan, Zack Twamley’s When Diplomacy Fails, and Jamie Redfern’s The History Of) and time spent in Italy, they decided to put together a podcast series on the unification of Italy in the nineteenth century. The topic wasn’t chosen based on any expert knowledge but with a growing interest in the era and spotting a gap in the podcast market, they sketched out an idea. My own background is actually rather similar – as a particle physics DPhil student (recently completed) with an amateur enthusiasm for history, deciding to do a blog on some books and podcasts that I felt hadn’t received that much attention. I also have a twin brother, with whom I once made a student radio show. With these similarities, I feel like I am fairly well placed to judge their efforts.

On my brief radio show, me and my brother would usually have taken turns to be lead presenter on different segments, and the Ashwells do similar in the fairly standard ‘lecture’ format of the podcast. They do however make the most of the co-presenter, with interjections from the other acting to break up the show and add some texture – something that other shows like When Diplomacy Fails are sometimes lacking. There’s a good dose of humour as well (I did love the suggestion that one can tell an Anti-Pope by placing him in a room with the real Pope and looking for gamma radiation). It’s nothing revolutionary, but they manage to take the common ‘History of X’ format and keep it fresh with the switch between the two presenters. One mild criticism I would have though is that while Benjamin sounds relaxed and comfortable on the microphone, Adam can sound a bit strained and distant; as if he is positioned ever so slightly too far from the microphone.

Italy in 1843As for the content itself, as they say in their opening episode, they’re not already experts in the field – and some of their Italian pronunciations will be off. However, they are clearly smart, organized and able to put the hard work and research into the show. The well-planned structure of the show is definitely one of the standout elements, they know how to stress elements and introduce characters such that the development of Italian culture (or culture in Italy) is smoothly introduced and any misconceptions or elements of confusion are cut out before they begin. Although “good structure” doesn’t really sound like a glamorous or fun feature, it works as a base from which the more eye-catching parts of the story can spring.

At time of writing I’m only about half way through the series (around episode 13), but there has also been a good use of the website so far – with a bibliography and a number of maps and images for reference. However it looks like this may tail off in the future with fewer images being added from later episodes. This may not be down to neglect however, most of these figures were used when setting up the background of the story.

We start with a number of episodes which run from the end of the Roman Empire to Charlemagne, from the early Medieval period to the Renaissance, and through the French Revolution. There are interesting stories here, but the podcast keeps on track and focuses on the relevant elements for the unification of Italy. They set up questions about nationalism, how unified Italy was then (and how unified it is now) and who really benefited by the unification. They also focus on getting the listener up to speed on the political and geographical history of the region. There are also some side podcasts purely on Venetian history, partly because it’s not as relevant to unification and partly because it’s utterly fascinating. Once these are through, the show settles down to something closer to the usual narrative ‘History Of’ style.

At first these tackle the story of Napoleon. Obviously this is a great one, but it’s also of great importance for the later unification of Italy – with his reorganization and reform providing a early model for what a united Italy could be. This tale extends over too much of Europe for a simple focus on Italy alone, and indeed the Ashwells give a broad history of Napoleon’s larger escapades. In the end, Bone-y will be defeated and die in exile but his impact on Europe and Italy would not disappear as easily. In the aftermath of his wars, the old orders would be restored in much of Europe but these would never be quite as stable as they had once been, and very soon revolutions would spring up again. This time though, some of these would be nationalist in nature, with figures like Guiseppe Mazzini and Guiseppe Garibaldi (of biscuit fame) aiming to produce a unified Italy.

The full story is not one that I know particularly well, but it’s definitely one that I’m very much enjoying finding out. This isn’t a historically irrelevant topic, and the unification of Italy is far from a closed book – only three months ago, Venice voted strongly for independence1 (albeit in a non-binding poll). The regional variations and knock on effects even fall beyond the sphere of politics, featuring heavily in many aspects of life (as I recently discovered in the excellent and highly recommended football book A Season With Verona by author Tim Parks). The story is told with this modern day relevance in mind, and the Ashwells do a good job of keeping this modernity and concept of continual (but not inevitable) change in the story.

This is a generally very competently made podcast, though I do still have a few issues with levels and editing but they’re relatively minor. For a topic which could definitely be better known outside of Italy, it tells it in a way that I imagine would work for a range of audiences. It’s detailed, but it introduces those details slowly and carefully enough for a complete novice to follow. The style using two alternating presenters is one that helps the show stand out from its contemporaries and keeps it from ever getting bogged down. It’s definitely worth a listen for anyone who enjoys this sort of narrative history or has an interest in Italy (past or present). Visit it at http://www.talkinghistorypodcast.com/.

1 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-europe-26604044

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Post 23: Talking History: Italian Unification Podcast

  1. Hi, this is Benjamin from Talking History: The Italian Unification. I’m flattered by your very kind and thorough review! We’d love to hear what you think about later episodes as you catch up to the most recent ones – we’re always looking for ways to improve the show.

    You’re right about there not being many new maps or pictures on the website recently. The main reason is that the borders have stopped changing for the moment, so there’s no need for new maps.

    I’d also be interested to hear more about the issues with levels and editing you mentioned. I think some of them have been fixed in later episodes, but it’s entirely possible that I’m totally unaware of others. (Speaking of editing problems, Adam just e-mailed me moments ago to point out a particularly noticeable editing gaffe in Episode 27, which we’ll try to fix tonight).

    Thanks again for the lovely review!

    1. Thanks very much for the comment! I was a bit wary about posting it while I still had plenty of episodes to go, so I will definitely try add an update to it at some point. I’m still listening, and enjoying it more and more as unification starts to rear its head.

      The levels and editing were pretty minor issues, but I felt there was just a little imbalance between you and Adam in terms of volume, background noise or something like that. Either would be fine on its own, but the transitions between them didn’t feel as smooth as they could have been – having said that, I do love what you do with two presenters so it does more than make up for that. I can’t actually remember what the editing issues were, I think there were just a few repetitions here and there that hadn’t been caught.

      And thanks as well for making the podcast. You clearly put a lot of work and enthusiasm into it.

    2. Hi Benjamin, I’m pretty much up to date now, and it has definitely become my favourite podcast of the moment. Just to give an update on the review/comment – you were correct, the episodes do seem to get better for editing/levels as they go along.

      Mentioning the lack of new maps in later episodes as well, it actually fits in with something else I’d praise – how well you have adjusted the show for changes in style and content: some episodes having a character focus, some covering a general topic, some providing recaps, different episodes covering different lengths of time … It’s all done rather well.

      Cheers,
      Philip

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s